The real reason Boeing's new plane crashed twice

Share
HTML-code

Comments • 16 529

  • Vox
    Vox   3 days back

    Like this video? Help us make more like it by becoming a member of the Vox Video Lab here on YouTube: http://bit.ly/vox-video-membership

    There are few things that we love more than blowing your mind with an obscure fact, or crafting a visually beautiful, reported explainer — but that work is expensive. Your membership will help fund more of that work, let us take on more ambitious series and stories, and keep our work free.

    So if you're interested in supporting our journalism and getting a peek into our process, please consider becoming a member of the Vox Video Lab today. http://bit.ly/video-lab

    • Guinness
      Guinness  30 minutes back

      Del Dmitrii planes, yes, because pilots are far more highly trained at flying than your average American or Italian driver, planes are far better maintained than average car and the sky is a lot more clear then your average road. So yeah, your average plane is. But not 737 Max's.

    • Guinness
      Guinness  33 minutes back

      Dexter Francis your understanding of the point i made and of how to argue a point correctly without reverting to a straw man is flawed, as what you say has nothing to do with what I said. But OK genius, if what you say is correct and it is solely down to pilot error, why are all 737 max's grounded and why are Boeing updating their mcats software and training? If there was burning wrong with the owner and the software and the training - why the fuss?

    • Dexter Francis
      Dexter Francis  2 hours back

      +Guinness - Your understanding of the certification process is flawed. The plane is not certified to fly safely outside it's placarded limits - which, based on the data in the Preliminary Report - is what the crew did for over three minutes before the crash.

    • uofawayne
      uofawayne  2 hours back

      Another example of corporate greed and negligent company executives making short-sighted decisions to drive profit in expense of innocent people.

  • 3rik R Vargas
    3rik R Vargas  5 minutes back

    It's very irresponsible to give final conclusions about an aerial accident by considering Youtube videos instead of a criminal investigation. This channel shall be banned!

    • Andrew Elwood
      Andrew Elwood  8 minutes back

      Nice work, very informative.

      • TheGranicd
        TheGranicd  10 minutes back

        Maybe they should have made landing gears longer and then engine wouldn`t have problems fitting. Would make it more costly tho.

        • Zero Hour
          Zero Hour  15 minutes back

          they didnt pay the mafia tax

          • Phurich Siri.
            Phurich Siri.  16 minutes back

            Defects in car production also cause a lot of casualty every year. However, it seems no one cares about it. Every one reacts so slow comparing to aviation industry.

            • Jason Shintani
              Jason Shintani  25 minutes back

              Even the 737-800s have engines that are much further forward and higher than the original 737s of the 1960's. Image search "1967 737" and you'll see the pencil-like engines tucked fully under the wing.

              • Robin durai
                Robin durai  28 minutes back

                Human life is less worth than profits for Boeing..:(

                • Brandon McLean
                  Brandon McLean  35 minutes back

                  Boeing did too many work arounds to get this plane off the ground. Instead of raising the plane and keeping the engine in the correct placement. Disgusting Boeing. I will never get on a plane that needs software to fix a "work around" issue. They did the same crap with the Dreamliner. Took a bunch of parts from different countrys that didn't match then put it together with work arounds. I will only book a flight with Airbus's from now on.

                  • s00s
                    s00s  36 minutes back

                    Southwest didn't even ground their fleet. I just got back from the airport after a trip on one of them. The whole time the engine was sputtering and constantly making high pitched shrieks and then going really quiet, over and over again, as well as sudden small turns, which were immediately negated with a manual turn in the other direction. Never flying Southwest again. Corporate scum

                    • Patrick Butler
                      Patrick Butler  39 minutes back

                      that’s why ya don’t let folks who live in mud huts fly jets

                      • Juan S
                        Juan S  41 minutes back

                        From th DC 10 Flying Coffin to the NEW & Improved Flying Coffin BOEING 737 MAX. History means NOTHING to these GREEDY BASTARDS..Jut look at the Old FORD PINTO etc, etc, etc, etc.

                        • Yaakov Kahn
                          Yaakov Kahn  43 minutes back

                          Umm if the whole problem was that the plane was too low to the ground, maybe invest in larger wheels.....

                          • Jslayallday92 S
                            Jslayallday92 S  44 minutes back

                            It’s important to recognize that most products, especially technologically advanced ones require multiple components and instruments that simply aren’t available in one place. Materials for production are sourced from all over the world. Assembly is made in stages and in different locations during the manufacturing process. All businesses practice this. This why it’s also difficult to pinpoint who is responsible for the tragic accident where people lost their lives because the parts making up the plane are from many different sources. I’m curious to why the MCAST wasn’t just turned off at the moment they lost control or just switch to manual? How much time was there between take off and it’s last communication before plummeting in the Java sea?

                            • Official kingawesome113
                              Official kingawesome113  48 minutes back

                              I would've lifted the plane a bit higher.

                              • Anshul Johri
                                Anshul Johri  54 minutes back

                                Lion air (JT 610) captain and main pilot Bhavye Suneja was my friend & neighbor. This video reminds of him again, takes me into deep silence and makes me think of how these big billionaires (better to call them white-collar murderers) are playing with the lives of innocent people just for few more billions.

                                • Random NPC
                                  Random NPC  59 minutes back

                                  All i need to know without watching this.. Anti stall system is activated (automatically)

                                  • Abodunrin Oluwafemi
                                    Abodunrin Oluwafemi  1 hours back

                                    Sue Boeing

                                    • Projectheureka
                                      Projectheureka  1 hours back

                                      Ummm.... For starters: in many U.S. right-wing states you have the legal rights to pursue and shoot ANYONE who pose a "perceived threat" to your life, rights, family and properties.

                                      That American vigilante law, FYI, does not exclude the shooting of the corrupt richs nor corrupt Executives who are knowingly mass murdering people, be their names BOEING or Perdue Pharma or even Mark Zuckerberg for that matter

                                      Achtung: I'm NOT suggesting hat ANYONE should go out and shoot corrupt Executives who hideously murder people, such as Zucks and the Perdue Pharma billionaires, for profits, but factually based on the U.Constitution's right to self-defense ALL U.S. Americans citizens do have that theoretical right to Stand Your Grounds even against mega Corporate billionaires.

                                      Until theory meets and becomes the common practise, you never know your real rights as a People nor as an individual.
                                      Carpe Diem, Americans and all of you childishly naive Earth' inhabitants!

                                      Godless Best,
                                      A.E.
                                      Projectheureka LLC

                                      • E
                                        E  1 hours back

                                        Boeing is murder at this point

                                        • Irfan Prabowo
                                          Irfan Prabowo  1 hours back

                                          My wife's bestfriend was on that plane (Lion Air). We don't need new software and training, we need justice.

                                          • Des
                                            Des  1 hours back

                                            I wouldn't fly in one of those now. Software update or not. Patches are fine for an iPhone or something non life critical, but for a jet.....

                                            • HighHeidYin
                                              HighHeidYin  1 hours back

                                              Sooooo..Am I supposed to be worried next time I fly? because the chances of flying with a 737 Max could be likely? or have they all been grounded and I've got nothing to worry about

                                              • imran shaikh
                                                imran shaikh  1 hours back

                                                Never trust money minded company they just play people emotion and their loved one never come back

                                                • Evans O
                                                  Evans O  1 hours back

                                                  If only Boeing put people before profits...

                                                  • ft55555
                                                    ft55555  1 hours back

                                                    Why ground the planes? Just let free market capitalism do its thing so that libertarians can get $25 flights on empty 737 Maxes.

                                                    • Joel Chia
                                                      Joel Chia  1 hours back

                                                      Greed.

                                                      • Kent Yang
                                                        Kent Yang  1 hours back

                                                        This was so educational. Thank you for doing the research !

                                                        • Ahsan Arshad
                                                          Ahsan Arshad  2 hours back

                                                          Instead of redesigning they put some fixes to compete ... absolutely disastorous....these guys should be in jail and sorry but ask them to redesign their plane..... don't need to put another fix

                                                          • Robert Lee
                                                            Robert Lee  2 hours back

                                                            You have to be able to overide the system. No red guarded kill switch ??

                                                            • Mickey Lewin
                                                              Mickey Lewin  2 hours back

                                                              Money changes everything.

                                                              • ali khazravi
                                                                ali khazravi  2 hours back

                                                                Beautifully edited and very well related, thanks god they cancel the Iranians order for it.

                                                                • Rich Trost
                                                                  Rich Trost  2 hours back

                                                                  What bothers me is that MCAS depended on a single angle of attack sensor unless you paid extra for input from both.  This strikes me as a major blunder where redundancy is a usually expected norm.

                                                                  • FRFM00
                                                                    FRFM00  2 hours back

                                                                    Satanic ritual, nothing more nothing less and no two ways about it.

                                                                    • Carl Rhode
                                                                      Carl Rhode  2 hours back

                                                                      This video is not the full truth! Boeing has raised the aircraft as well to accommodate the new engines. Please note that this is not a profit scandal. Boeing has made economy their philosophy. Planes like the 787 and 747-8 show this. What they made was a much needed update to the world's most famous airplane. Surely they also attempted to make the plane safer as well. A plane crash can destroy a company completely. Do you really think Boeing would be stupid enough to release an aircraft that they know would crash? This was an accident. Emphasis on the word "accident". Thank you.

                                                                      • Adrian Cheung
                                                                        Adrian Cheung  2 hours back

                                                                        This is what happened when there is a competition and money is involve, and playing with innocent lives.

                                                                        • Mary Rafuse
                                                                          Mary Rafuse  2 hours back

                                                                          Money and market share over safety. Way to go Boeing!

                                                                          • trident3b
                                                                            trident3b  2 hours back

                                                                            silly question if i may... but why didn't boeing simply make the landing gear longer/higher (just like the AB)?? That would have raised the aircraft to the Airbus height. It can't be that expensive or difficult to enlarge the undercarriage, surely?
                                                                            Also, the americans are so quick to issue draconian sentences for things far less than this, but Boeing gets, and will get, away with it. Oh but we must get people like assange who expose extreme and deliberate atrocities, even with the threat of death for exposing others committing such heinous crimes.... and with this almost 400 people with little kids all stuck in a fuselage sent to their deaths, those responsible for that will get off scot-free.

                                                                            • Sanjay Pathak
                                                                              Sanjay Pathak  2 hours back

                                                                              Irrational Exuberance .... “you will be flying the same plane as before” or am I making it up?

                                                                              And how far does minimal i-pad training go .... especially if the god Boeing says ... this is enough!

                                                                              There is a common thread of excessive clever dickiness running through both the in-service performance of the airbus neo and the boeing mcas engines ... be honest ... these are resl unsuspecting people being killed ....

                                                                              • Brian Hall
                                                                                Brian Hall  2 hours back

                                                                                Boeing needs to get the pants sued off of them and a number of executives need to go to jail.

                                                                                • brandi williams
                                                                                  brandi williams  2 hours back

                                                                                  this is information we all already knew since the incident happened last month. nothing new here.

                                                                                  • Noah R
                                                                                    Noah R  2 hours back

                                                                                    It really sucks how much corporations care more about money than human lives

                                                                                    • Bernal
                                                                                      Bernal  2 hours back

                                                                                      Very nice video , Tks for taking the time to do your research to explain the facts of what happen ...

                                                                                      • zoperxplex
                                                                                        zoperxplex  2 hours back

                                                                                        Gravity.

                                                                                        • dan italia
                                                                                          dan italia  2 hours back

                                                                                          put those resposible in jail..its the design and function of the plane is the problem..software to powerful .but if the pilot will take control of the plane the stall will be their problem..there is no solution but to ground all the 737 for good..

                                                                                          • Lance Roark
                                                                                            Lance Roark  2 hours back

                                                                                            Boeing: your max angle of climb is 35°
                                                                                            Pilot: copy that, we’ll simply set climb to 35° and quit flying the plane.
                                                                                            Boeing: no, you need to fly the plane and make sure the plane doesn’t increase its angle of climb
                                                                                            Pilot: no, set it and forget it, that’s how I fly


                                                                                            St Peter: Pilot, do you know what you did wrong?
                                                                                            Pilot: yeah, I took control of a plane that had new engines
                                                                                            Pete: yeah, not really. Why don’t you take the elevator to the ground floor. You wanna act the fool, we’ll treat you like a fool.

                                                                                            Disclaimer: Good Ole Pete isn’t really in charge, nor does he work entry security.

                                                                                            • dunichtich100
                                                                                              dunichtich100  2 hours back

                                                                                              Airbus for the win! God bless all the families who lost a beloved one! ❤

                                                                                              • Tomaz
                                                                                                Tomaz  2 hours back

                                                                                                God damn Boeing greed. Time to short that sh*thole company.